Friday 18 August 2017

Shelby Lynne & Allison Moorer - Not Dark Yet, album review



Wonderful Expectations

The one original song on the album, Is It Too Much? co-written by Lynne and Moore, is a plaintive, questioning yearn for commitment and care to share a burden, the lamenting guitar-work carrying it along emotively. The vocal harmonising is beautiful, and the answer is of course how this singing together here and a lifetime of shared experience binds the sisters closely and poignantly.

The other songs are covers of variously Bob Dylan, The Louvin Brothers, Merle Haggard, Nick Cave, Nirvana, Jason Isbell/Amanda Shires and others.

The more overtly contemporary songs get a mixed rendition: The Killers’ My List starts the album and is Band-like, it seems to me, anthemic organ and piano rises, and the vocal harmonies sweetly tight as they will be throughout the album; Nirvana’s Lithium is bound to engender the poles of liking, its ‘heaviness’ either a welcome tangent or intrusive divergence from the whole, the dissonant harmonies totally in keeping with the song’s origins and, for me, a stroke of fun, the line I’m so horny seeming quite corny in the lyrical surrounds of all the others on the album.

They took a risk. The Louvin Brothers’ Every Time You Leave is more classic Country lament and bears the production affection for such from Teddy Thompson who has overseen the whole project. Dylan’s title track is delivered with marching percussion, organ underpinning, and individual/dueting vocals that rise in emotion with the organ and piano scoring.

The Isbell/Squires song The Color of a Cloudy Day is a pretty song prettily delivered here, and Merle Haggard’s Silver Wings follows this with exquisite vocal harmonising as well as crisp soloing – obvious, but these vocal are simply superb. I don’t believe in an interventionist god is the great opening line from Nick Cave’s Into My Arms and its assertion belies the tender love song it is and which gets sung with a sensitive asserting of love by the sisters here. This is gorgeous.

The whole album is essentially gorgeous. Subtle throughout, this will grow with playing as the fine nuances become expectations. On my fourth play, those expectations are always met with such pleasure.


No comments:

Post a Comment