Nearly, But No Blubbering
I am still buzzing/affected by Crosby, Stills and Nash’s Thursday
concert, and being reminded now in other ways by listening to a bootleg of
their Royal Albert Hall performance on the 9
th October where the set
list was very similar.
This review could be either extremely long in its unbridled enthusiasm,
or brief – but still in its unbridled enthusiasm. Needs must and I will go for
the latter. Or try to. One interesting place to start is in stating that on
stage you had someone who played with Buffalo Springfield, someone who played
with The Hollies, and someone who played with The Byrds. Consummate credibility
already. And then you had the three members of their first incarnation, and
then with the addition of Neil Young, and variously after that [Stills/Young,
for example, and more consistently Crosby and Nash as a duo] and these guys
played Woodstock and became the epitome of the West Coast sound and just so
much phenomenally more. That lineage/history had massive much to do with the
highly emotive state I found myself in when seeing them on Thursday.
I don’t normally sing along at gigs, but when I tried to join
in with those opening first classic songs – Carry
On and Questions – I found myself
welling up. Pathetic I know, but I am not embarrassed to admit, and I think it
was all about the expectation of going to see these musical giants but also,
obviously, all that history of what they have achieved and how much their early
days impacted on my youth and consequently my views and attitudes and – well,
you know the powerful symbiosis that exists between adolescence and musical
[and the other within: lyrical, political, reminiscence] influence. It was all
there.
Needless to say I didn’t blubber at those early moments and
nor did I later when I managed to sing along to other classics. And they were
the classics, as well as very recent and other material along their long way
together and separately. Each in fact got their solo spotlights, even if this
was together but focusing on the songwriting individuality.
I’m not going to review the music because it doesn’t need
that. But what matters is how they sounded now: the vocal harmonising was as outstanding
as ever, Crosby and Nash in particular quite pristine. The backing band was
remarkably tight and gifted in support, but it was the three up front and
centre and foregrounded on the mics that carried the evening to its aural
heights. Stephen Stills is known to have hearing difficulties and a consequent
impact on his vocals, but this wasn’t even that noticeable on his solo contributions,
and certainly not in unison. Or if it was noticeable – I don’t need to
whitewash this performance – it was the simple reality of age and the years of
whatever was done to affect that. And Stills’ gravelly, bluesy vocal had such
an impact that evening, as did his superb guitar soloing: the crackling of the
feedback controlled into the most mellow of full, beautiful sound, but also
erupting into the wildest rock. The Crosby/Nash duet of Guinevere, performed thousands of times by these two, was sublime.
The gig began precisely at 8pm, the guys had a 20 minute
break, and then it finished at just after 11pm, all packed with quality and
even more history in the making for me. Closing songs were Almost Cut My Hair – Crosby’s vocal soaring in its clarity – and then
Wooden Ships, with the encore – and as
Nash said, it couldn’t be any other, not having been played yet – Sweet Judy Blue Eyes. There had been
standing ovations throughout the set, and I was one of the first, compelled to
react [so much better than shedding tears, no matter how joyous!], so can you
imagine the reaction at the very end?!
And do you know, I’m still buzzing.